We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Are Smart Smoke Detectors Worth It?

The Google Nest Protect in a ceiling.

For the last half-century, smoke alarms have toed the line between “essential life-saving product” and “shockingly outdated annoyance.” But if you’re willing to spend some extra cash, you can now buy a smart smoke detector. These internet-connected alarms can send remote alerts to your phone, integrate with other smart products, and turn off using simple voice commands.

But smart smoke alarms cost over $100. They aren’t cheap, and like typical smoke detectors, they expire after a decade. So, are smart smoke detectors worth the money?

What Is a Smart Smoke Detector?

Your average smoke alarm has just a few functions. It makes an awful screaming sound when it detects smoke, it chirps when its battery is dying, and if you’re lucky, it has a snooze button.

Smart smoke detectors offer all three of these features with some neat improvements. They can send alerts to your phone when they detect smoke or carbon monoxide (even when you’re not home). And in the event of a false alarm, you can temporarily disable smart smoke detectors using your phone or voice assistant.

Interestingly, Google’s Nest Protect will warn you before an alarm goes off. Its built-in speaker will say that there’s smoke in a room, giving you time to prepare your ears or disable the alarm.

And if you install smart smoke detectors across your home, they will automatically form an interconnected system. This means that all of your alarms will go off at once, and interestingly, it allows your alarms to tell you which room is smokey or full of carbon monoxide.

I just need to clarify two things. First, you don’t need to buy smart smoke alarms to have an interconnected system. Battery-powered alarms from brands like Kiddie offer interconnection features. And if your home’s hard-wired alarm system isn’t interconnected, an electrician can get the job done for you.

Also, smart smoke detectors aren’t “better at detecting smoke,” or whatever. They use the same components as any regular smoke or CO detector. The only real difference is that smart smoke alarms are more convenient, can send remote alerts, and can integrate with your smart home.

Best Smart Smoke Detector

Google Nest Protect - Smoke Alarm - Smoke Detector and Carbon Monoxide Detector - Battery Operated , White - S3000BWES

Google's battery-powered Nest Protect alarm detects both smoke and carbon monoxide. It offers smartphone or voice assistant control and automatically interconnects with other Nest Protect alarms. Nest Protect works with Google Assistant or Alexa.

Smart Home Integration Could Help In an Emergency

The Google Nest Protect in a smokey room.

We love finding new ways to automate smart home devices. A smart motion sensor in your bathroom can control a set of smart bulbs, for example. But what if we used a smart smoke detector for home automation? That’s a crazy idea, right?

Well, maybe it’s not so crazy. In the event of an emergency, your smart smoke detector could automatically turn on the lights, unlock the front door, shut down your HVAC system, and trigger the alarms in your outdoor security cameras.

Those who are tech-savvy could find further integrations using IFTTT or other protocols. Maybe you want your neighbors to get a text if the alarm goes off and you’re away from home—the possibilities are endless.

These are small things, for sure, but they could save someone’s life during a house fire. Just try to avoid any false alarms if your smart smoke detector is linked with anything obnoxious, like the alarms in your outdoor cameras.

They’re Cheaper Than Professionally-Monitored Alarms

A carbon monoxide smartphone alert from Nest Protect.

You’ve probably realized by now, but smart smoke alarms aren’t cheap. A single Nest Protect costs $120, which is about what you’d pay for a four-pack of basic “combination” smoke detectors. Old-fashioned ionization alarms cost even less money, and if you’re a homeowner, your local fire station may provide them for free.

It doesn’t help that smoke detectors only last 10 years. This isn’t some arbitrary rule, by the way. All smoke detectors have a 10-year expiry date to fit regulations. Smart alarms like the Nest Protect genuinely stop working on their 10th birthday—something that’s confirmed by early customers.

But here’s the thing; smart smoke detectors can send you alerts when you’re away from home. They offer serious peace of mind. And in the past, this peace of mind was only available to those who could afford a professional monitoring service.

Professional monitoring services, also called home security services, usually cost around $25 to $80 a month for basic burglary, fire, and smoke monitoring. And that’s after you pay $300 to $600 on equipment. A smart smoke alarm is a much cheaper option.

A quick side-note—ADT can integrate its home security systems with Google Nest products. If you already have a professional security system, Nest Protect could still be a valuable addition to your home.

Alexa and Apple HomeKit Compatibility

Onelink Smoke Detector and Carbon Monoxide Detector | Battery Powered| First Alert

First Alert's Onelink alarm detects both smoke and carbon monoxide. It's battery-powered, offers control through your phone or voice assistant, and automatically interconnects with identical Onelink alarms. Plus, it works with Alexa and Apple HomeKit.

Should You Buy a Smart Smoke Detector?

The Fist Alert Onelink smart smoke detector.
First Alert

Smart smoke alarms offer more peace of mind and convenience than basic smoke detectors. They can send you alerts when you’re away from home, warn you when an alarm might go off, or even integrate with your other smart home devices.

But smart smoke detectors aren’t cheap. You need some serious cash if you want to buy more than just one of these things. While I certainly think a smart smoke detector is worth the investment,

For what it’s worth, you can get remote smoke alarm alerts without buying a $120 smoke detector. Your Nest speakers, cameras, and doorbells can alert you to fire alarms when you subscribe to Nest Aware, which costs $6 a month (and includes a bunch of other features). Amazon Alexa products offer similar functionality when you join Ring Protect Plus for $10 a month.

The Best Smart Home Devices of 2023

Google Nest Hub (2nd Gen)
Best Smart Display
Google Nest Hub (2nd Gen)
Sonos Era 100
Best Smart Speaker
Sonos Era 100
Philips Hue
Best Smart Light Bulb
Philips Hue
Lutron Caseta Smart Start Kit
Best Smart Switch
Lutron Caseta Smart Start Kit
ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium
Best Premium
ecobee Smart Thermostat Premium
August Wi-Fi Smart Lock
Best Smart Lock
August Wi-Fi Smart Lock
Ring Doorbell 4
Best Video Doorbell
Ring Doorbell 4
Arlo Pro 4 Spotlight Camera
Best Indoor Security Camera
Arlo Pro 4 Spotlight Camera
Andrew Heinzman Andrew Heinzman
Andrew is the News Editor for Review Geek, where he covers breaking stories and manages the news team. He joined Life Savvy Media as a freelance writer in 2018 and has experience in a number of topics, including mobile hardware, audio, and IoT. Read Full Bio »