We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

7 Al-lure-ing Fishing Subscription Boxes for the Avid Fisherman

Fishing Subscription Box best fishing gear bait tackle lures fly fishing lake fishing ice fishing

Fishing is a relaxing recreational activity and a popular competitive sport, and it’s all about having the right gear to get the job done. These fishing subscription boxes offer the best gear for any and all types of fishing enthusiasts.

Most monthly fishing subscription boxes ship a combination of gear like lures, bait, tackles, guides, and other extras, most of which are from popular name brands. A few boxes are general purpose, with stuff for many of the most commonly encountered fish species, while others focus on just one species. Overall, these are fun gifts for anyone wanting to fish casually or competitively.

Update, 5/11/22: Verified content, links, and pricing are up to date. Replaced Reel Tackle Box with Lucky Tackle Box.

More Than Just Gear: Mystery Tackle Box

Mystery Tackle Box fishing pro box inshore saltwater fishing panfish catfish expert fishing videos
Mystery Tackle Box

Mystery Tackle Box is a great fishing subscription box for newbies and seasoned anglers alike. When you first sign up, the service will have you choose from the basic Regular box or upgrade to either the Pro box or the Elite box. From there, you’ll specify which type of fish species you want gear for (from choices like bass, inshore saltwater, panfish and trout, walleye, or multi-species (which includes stuff for each of those species).

Every box is loaded with exclusive and limited-edition fishing gear. You can pause your plan as needed, and subscribing gets you access to how-to videos, expert content, and contests on the company’s website.

More Than Just Gear

Mystery Tackle Box

Get gear for fishing bass, saltwater, panfish, trout, walleye, and others and expert advice.

Oceans of Options: Lucky Tackle Box

Lucky Tackle Box home page, showing off what's in the subscription box
Lucky Tackle Box

Lucky Tackle Box delivers a wonderful variety of curated fishing gear to your doorstep each month, including name-brand lures and bait. Boxes also include some nice accessories you’ll need at some point, like attractants and pliers. Heck, they even throw in an educational magazine that shows you how to use every item and maximize your odds of catching some fish with them.

You’ll have three boxes to choose from here: The Classic, a basic pick that includes 5-7 items; the Classic XL, which includes 7-9 items; and the Classic Extreme, which includes 16 items. No matter which box you choose from, the service gives you the choice of making your box bass-specific or opening it up to include stuff for multiple species.

Oceans of Options

Lucky Tackle Box

Choose a fishing subscription box for bass or a whole variety of species, and get up to 16 new items each box.

Great for Bass Fishing: MONSTERBASS

Monsterbass best subscription box for bass fishing regional big bass fishing bass bait

MONSTERBASS is impressive because of its precision focus on big bass fishing. Bait and gear are hand-selected by regional fishing experts like Alex Rudd and Travis Manson, who know exactly what will catch the eyes of bass commonly found in your locale.

All you need to do is tell MONSTERBASS what state you live in and whether you prefer to fish from the bank, a boat, or both. The experts will take it from there and send you the best bait for your region from brand names like Strike King, Daiichi, V&M, Yum, and War Eagle.

Great for Bass Fishing


Get expert-curated gear for bass fishing in your geographic region.

Fabulous for Fly Fishing: Freestone Fly Fishing Company

Freestone Fly Fishing Company best fishing subscription box for anglers flies and patterns for trout fly tying warm water salmon steelhead
Freestone Fly Fishing Company

If fly fishing is your life, don’t miss the flies and gear offered by Freestone Fly Fishing Company. Each month, you’ll receive a comprehensive Fly Guide, some stickers, 12-24 premium flies, and 4-5 pieces of essential angling gear from popular fly fishing brands each month. The fly fishing subscription box also gets you a one-year membership to Trout Unlimited. When signing up, you’ll select which box you want: the Freshwater Trout Box, the Fly-Tying Box, the Saltwater Box, the Salmon/Steelhead Box, or the Warmwater Bass Box.

Fabulous for Fly Fishing

Freestone Fly Fishing Company

Get boxes for fly-tying, trout fishing, warm water fishing, and saltwater fishing.

Terrific for Trout Fishing: True Fly Supply

True Fly Supply best fishing subscription box for trout fishing warm water stillwater saltwater
True Fly Supply

With options for trout, warm water, and saltwater fishing, True Fly Supply has the flies and gear you need for your next fishing trip. The Trout Supply Drop option includes 24 trout flies in six patterns, the Warm Water Supply Drop option has 16 flies in four patterns for stillwater, and the Saltwater Supply Drop features nine flies in three patterns for United States coastlines.

Each monthly box includes a fun mystery item, as well as a leader, educational card, sticker, and candy. However, as of December, the ability to switch between boxes each month is not yet available, so choose your box carefully. The company has other subscription boxes available, too, beyond trout-specific ones, like for fly tying and saltwater.

Terrific for Trout Fishing

True Fly Supply

Enjoy flies, gear, and other extras for trout, warm water, and saltwater fishing.

Best for All-Around Outdoorsy Types: The Sportsman’s Box

The Buddy Outdoors home page, featuring its subscription box
Buddy Outdoors

For those that enjoy hunting as well as fishing, The Sportsman’s Box has gear for both activities. The team that creates this subscription box field tests the gear, apparel, and food themselves before sending it out in monthly boxes. The Starter box is for casual hunters and anglers, and includes to two to three select items like tools, bait and tackle, and hunting accessories.

The Original box is for avid hunters and anglers and comes with three to five personalized items like apparel, necessary gear, bait and tackle, and tools. The Denali box starts costs a bit more, but includes four to six premium items like game cameras, apparel, essential gear, or lifestyle items.

Best for All-Around Outdoorsy Types

The Sportsman's Box

Get new gear monthly for hunting and fishing, like bait, tackle, and premium hunting accessories.

Curated Choices: Warriors Tackle Supply

Warrior's Tackle Supply best curated fishing subscription box perch pike walleye
Warrior’s Tackle Supply

You can enjoy Warriors Tackle Supply as a one-time purchase or as a recurring monthly subscription. The service offers a curated box each month with lures and gear tailored to your specific fishing needs. When signing up, choose from the Standard box for $23.99 per month, the XL box for $29.99 per month, or the Pro box for $42.99 per month. Although Warriors Tackle Supply does not offer species-specific boxes like many of the others do, you can select a few fish you generally target like perch, trout, pike, or walleye.

Curated Choices

Warriors Tackle Supply

Get personalized picks for gear and lures for your specific fishing needs.

Suzanne Humphries Suzanne Humphries
Suzanne Humphries was a Commerce Editor for Review Geek. She has over seven years of experience across multiple publications researching and testing products, as well as writing and editing news, reviews, and how-to articles covering software, hardware, entertainment, networking, electronics, gaming, apps, security, finance, and small business. Read Full Bio »