These Board Games are Perfect for ‘Among Us’ Fans

Among Us banner
InnerSloth

The video game Among Us has skyrocketed in popularity over the past year. Likewise, board games have also seen an uptick in popularity thanks to the pandemic and stay-at-home orders. But what if you could have board games that closely resemble Among Us? Well, you’ve come to the right place.

How to Choose the Right Among Us-like Board Game

Now more than ever, people are staying at home with some free time on their hands. Board games are a fantastic at-home activity that won’t break the bank.

There are a few things to consider before picking up an Among Us-like board game.

  • Competition: As you’d expect, in order for a game to be similar to Among Us, it’ll need to have a social deduction (hidden impostor) aspect where you can’t trust anyone. In some games, nobody knows who’s on their team, and in others, only one person or team knows.
  • Length of play: Not everyone has a couple of hours to kill. Some games can be finished in under half an hour, while others could go on for an afternoon. Make sure you pick a game that fits the length of time you need.
  • Number of players: You’ll need to check the number of players a game requires. If it’s just you and your significant other, check out some two-player options. Wanting to play with 20 or more people? There are options for that, too.

Now that you’ve considered the three most important aspects of an Among Us-like game, it’s time to pick a game (or two, or three) out.

The Menace Among Us

The Menace Among Us board game box
smirkanddagger

The Menace Among Us follows a similar theme as Among Us. You’re on a damaged spaceship as oxygen is running low. The twist? As you and your crewmates try to repair the ship, the more moves you make the less oxygen you’ll have, bringing you closer to death. Of course, there’ll be a hidden impostor among your group of friends. Their objective is to sabotage your plan and kill you off one at a time, undetected.

The game runs about 40 to 60 minutes and is playable with four to eight players. At the beginning of the game, each player chooses a random Agenda. The available Agendas include: Crew member, Menace (impostor), or the Coward (think of them as a third impostor. Not loyal, but always on the “winning” side.)

The Menace Among Us ultimately ends when one of the following three things happen: if all Crew members finish all their tasks, if the Menace kills off all Crew, or if the entire Crew dies from lack of oxygen.

The Menace Among Us

Smirk & Dagger The Menace Among Us

It's in the name, this game is very similar to the popular Among Us video game. You can't go wrong here.

Burke’s Gambit

Burke's Gambit board game box art
WizKids

Watch out, an Alien is on board! In Burke’s Gambit, you have several roles: Captain, Marine, Comms, and Officer. Each person takes a turn rolling the die with outcomes, such as healing yourself, damaging another player, or an engine power up, lowering the time it takes to get back to Earth.

The infected player’s objective is to sabotage the mission so that the ship never reaches Earth. The game is time sensitive and goes on for several rounds. Once time is up, players must vote someone off into the void. If the infected player gets ejected—congrats, you’ve won the game.

Burke’s Gambit is a turn-based card game with an estimated playtime of around 20 minutes. You can play with anywhere between four to eight players. It’s great if you’re looking for a quick game to play.

Burke's Gambit

WizKids Burke's Gambit

Watch out, there's an Alien on board! It's your duty to find out who the Alien is and make sure he or she doesn't sabotage your mission to get back to Earth!

The Resistance

The Resistance board game box art
Indie Boards and Cards

You’re part of a rebellion that has been suppressed by the government. Work as a team to take back your freedom. But don’t get too cocky, as there are a few spies (the Imperial Spies) that have infiltrated the Resistance, and it’s your job to figure out who you can trust, otherwise, they’ll sabotage your mission.

Unlike other games on this list, The Resistance has no player eliminations. This means that you’ll have to figure out the spies early on and keep an eye on them. Players will play for three to five rounds, which consist of the Leader creating a plan for a certain number of players. Everyone will need to vote whether or not they approve or deny the assignment. Once approved, each player can secretly decide to Support or Sabotage the mission at hand.

When either team, the Resistance or the Empire, wins three rounds they will be declared the winner. The game runs for about 30 minutes and can be played with 5-10 players.

The Resistance

The Resistance (The Dystopian Universe)

Take back your freedom with The Resistance! But be careful, there may be a few spies among your ranks.

Mafia: The World’s Deadliest Board Game

Mafia: The World's Deadliest Board Game box and cards
Laurence King

Are you sus? In Mafia, Villagers will have to work together and identify the Mafia that lives alongside them. If you’re part of the Mafia, your job is to lie and pretend you’re a Villager, otherwise, you run the risk of getting executed (and nobody wants to be executed).

There’s a Moderator that keeps track of what’s going on throughout the day and night. Everyone gets a randomly selected role which consists of a doctor, civilian, mayor, mafia, and a few others. You mustn’t tell anyone what your role is, and each role has a specific duty.

The game has quite the learning curve as there are three “levels” you can play it. In the game’s most basic form, the judge asks all players to close their eyes and then proceeds to ask the Mafia to open their eyes and discreetly picks a victim. The victim is then announced, and living players will need to identify a suspect. The game continues until either all mafia or civilians have been killed.

At least six players are recommended and the game can take anywhere between 15-60 minutes depending on how fast players are eliminated.

Mafia: The World's Deadliest Board Game

Mafia: The World's Deadliest Party Game

Are you part of the Mafia? Are you a Villager? Are you part of the Mafia pretending to be a Villager? Only one way to find out...

Dead of Winter

Dead of Winter board game box art
Fantasy Flight Games

Paranoia to the greatest! The gist of Dead of Winter is you’re a survivor in a colony with zombies roaming the Earth. At the begging of the game, players decide on a main objective survivors need to complete in order to win.

The best mechanic to Dead of Winter is the Betrayer card. Yes, it’s there but it’s not required in order to play. Yes, there’s a chance it never gets drawn. Paranoia indeed. In addition to the main objective, each player has their own issues to deal with, such as finding supplies in order to stay alive.

Dead of Winter is one of the more accessible games on our list in terms of the number of players. It can be played with anywhere between two and five players. Although you’ll need to put some time aside for it as a single game can run anywhere between 60 minutes to 120 minutes.

Dead of Winter

Dead of Winter

Got a little more time on your hands? Have friends who are super paranoid? Dead of Winter will keep you on the edge of your seat. Just be careful, there might be a Betrayer among the group.

Ultimate Werewolf: Deluxe Edition

Ultimate Werewolf Deluxe Edition box art
Bezier Games

Ultimate Werewolf is a straightforward game. There are two teams: Villagers and Werewolves. The Villagers have no idea who the Werewolves are and the Werewolves must lie and try to vote out all of the Villagers.

And just like Mafia, Ultimate Werewolf has a Moderator keeping track of what happens during the game. The game has a concept of day and night, and during each day a player is voted out based on whether players believe that person is a Werewolf. And at night, Werewolves do the same. The game ends once all Werewolves or all Villagers are eliminated.

Ultimate Werewolf runs about 30 minutes and can play be played with 5-75 players. It’s recommended that you try to stick with 15-20 players for the best experience.

Ultimate Werwolf: Deluxe Edition

Bezier Board Games Ultimate Werewolf Deluxe Edition Black

Are you team Villagers or team Werewolves? Is one of your friends acting sus? Are they really a Werwolf pretending to be a Villager?

Secret Hitler

Secret Hitler render with box art, cards, and the board
Secret Hitler

Potentially controversial name aside, Secret Hitler takes place in 1930s Germany. There are three teams: Liberals, Fascists, and Hitler himself. At the beginning of each game, every player closes their eyes. The Fascists are then asked to open their eyes, letting each other know who’s on their team. Hitler’s eyes are still closed, but he or she gives a thumbs up so the Fascists know who they are. The Liberals have no idea who anyone is (including members of their own team).

Each round, players must elect a President and a Chancellor. Both players will work together and pass a law by drawing from the deck. Players will have to decide whether or not if they’ve been betrayed or if it’s just the luck of the draw.

The game runs for about 45 minutes and can be played with 5-10 players. Secret Hitler is a load of fun, especially further into the game where everyone is screaming over one another.

Secret Hitler

Secret Hitler

Now is the time to fight against the government and take out the Fascists and Hitler.

The Crew: Quest for Planet Nine

The Crew: Quest for Planet Nine box art
Thames & Kosmos

Enjoy the silence while playing Among Us? Well, The Crew: Quest for Planet Nine may be right for you. The game takes the “space” aspect to the next level. You can’t breathe in space therefore the game is played in complete silence. So, you’ll have to get creative and find other ways to communicate. At the beginning of the game, players start with cards of different suits and numbers. Each round, a player gets a chance to play a card, and the player with the highest card claims all the cards.

To “win” or succeed in their mission, you’ll need to get specific cards to certain players. You have to be careful, though, as accidentally playing the wrong card can cause some serious chaos, potentially causing you to lose the mission.

The Crew: Quest for Planet Nine can be played with two to five players, and the game is rather short with an average playing time of 20 minutes. It’s a fantastic game if you’re short on time and are looking for some quick fun.

The Crew: Quest for Planet Nine

The Crew - Quest for Planet Nine | Card Game | Kennerspiel des Jahres Winner | Cooperative Space Adventure | 2 to 5 Players | Ages 10 and up | Trick-Taking | 50 Levels of Difficulty | Endless Replay

Shhhhh... don't speak. This game takes the "space" theme to the extreme. You have no oxygen in space, therefore you cannot speak. Find another way to communicate!

Peter Cao Peter Cao
Peter is a freelance writer for Review Geek. He started out 7 years ago writing about jailbreaking the iPhone and that evolved into writing about general Apple. And now? He’s just writing about tech. He’s written for several major online publications in the past and has written several thousand news and reviews articles over the years. Read Full Bio »

The above article may contain affiliate links, which help support Review Geek.